|
|
Hi Roger, A conditional premise is not an argument but a claim, more precise a simple one. There is no reasoning in a conditional statement. See the e-book Topic refining Claims no. 14. So an If.. then statement should not be represented as an argument with a contention and a premise. Can you give a link to (part of) a map in which you are dealing with this example? (When you do, please use Map references). BTW:
Regards, Timo |
by
timo
|
Hi Roger, Will answer your post asap. I plan to answer your question in such a way that it gives information too on what is called the problem of so-called ‘cheap co-premises’. Regards, Timo |
by
timo
|
Timo, Thanks for this response; I've only just seen it. I will check out the links you provide. Regards, Roger |
Be nice! Make everyone feel welcome to participate in the conversation. Be constructive! Assume and demonstrate good faith. Take a tone of actionable, professional, and courteous suggestions. Be specific! When applicable, make your map public and include it with your post, or include a screenshot or photo of your project.
I have worked my way through the Rationale tutorials and I'm now working on a set of argument maps to represent Thomas Aquinas' Five Ways. During the tutorial (and from the e-book), I built myself a little mind map of guidance on claim definition.
As I reviewed my first map with this guidance, I found I had entered several claims in the form:
if x, then y
Sometimes in the form of a question:
if God does not need a cause, why does the universe?
This clearly transgresses rules about reasoning in boxes and claims being capable of yes/no evaluation. So I have represented this as two claims: a parent claim, y, with supporting reason x.
What I'm a bit concerned about is that this representation hides, at least, partially the element of conditionality that implicit in the "if".
Does anyone have a comments on whether this is the best approach.
BTW, I am writing up my experience on my blog. Anyone interested can find the posts here:
https://oddrops.wordpress.com/?s=rationale
Regards,
Roger
PS Despite ticking the "notify me of replies" box, I am not getting any notifications. Anyone else finding this?